hot water wollongong

Heat Pump vs Solar Hot Water for Your Illawarra Home: How CS Plumbing Services Helps You Choose the Right System

If the old electric tank in your Illawarra home is getting tired, you may be weighing up heat pump vs solar hot water. Both systems cost more to buy than a standard electric tank but can be cheaper to run, so the better choice comes down to your roof, your yard and the times of day your household uses hot water.

CS Plumbing Services installs both types of system across Wollongong and the Illawarra. Owner Sandro Contarin has held a NSW plumbing licence since 1992. This guide sets out how each system works, where each one suits a home best and what we look at before recommending one.

Key Takeaways

  • A heat pump heats water from the warmth in the air, so it does not need any space on your roof.
  • Solar hot water needs a sunny roof facing roughly north with little shade, especially in winter.
  • Households that use most of their hot water early in the morning tend to lean on a solar booster more often.
  • Noise, the install spot and your existing tank all affect which system suits your home.

How Does a Heat Pump Hot Water System Work?

A heat pump uses electricity to move heat out of the surrounding air and into the water in its tank, rather than heating the water directly with an element. The Australian Government’s energy.gov.au guide to hot water systems says heat pumps use 30% of the energy of a conventional electric hot water system.

Heat pumps come in two main layouts. In an integrated unit the compressor sits on top of the tank, so it looks much like a standard electric tank and connects the same way. In a split unit the compressor and fan sit in a separate outdoor unit, and the tank can go somewhere else. Your Home, the Australian Government’s guide to sustainable homes, says the two units are usually limited to 10 to 15 metres apart.

Many heat pumps also have a boost element that heats the water directly in very cold weather or when the household uses a lot of hot water at once. If that element runs often, the running cost goes up. You can read more about the systems we fit on our heat pump hot water installation page.

How Does a Solar Hot Water System Work?

A solar hot water system uses collectors or evacuated tubes on the roof to absorb heat from the sun and carry it into an insulated storage tank. Your Home’s guide to hot water systems says that, depending on your climate, a solar system can provide up to 90 percent of your hot water.

There are two common layouts. A roof-mounted system keeps the tank and collectors together on the roof. A split system puts the collectors on the roof and the tank at ground level, which takes weight off the roof and makes the tank easier to reach. We install and service both layouts, and the choice depends on the roof structure, access to the tank and what you prefer.

We integrate an electric or gas booster with the solar systems we install. The booster heats the water on cloudy days, or when the household uses more hot water than the sun has heated. Our solar hot water installation page covers new installations, replacements and servicing.

Solar Hot Water

Heat Pump vs Solar Hot Water: Which Uses Less Energy?

Both systems use far less energy than a standard electric tank, and Your Home describes them as much more efficient than the other options. The difference between the two depends more on your home than on the technology itself. A solar system works best with strong sun on the roof, and a heat pump works best in warmer, more humid air.

Your Home measures heat pump efficiency with a figure called the coefficient of performance, which compares the heat delivered to the electricity used. Heat pumps sit at around 3 to 5, while a new electric storage tank sits at about 0.95. Your Home also warns that this figure changes with the air temperature and the water temperature, so a brochure figure is only a rough guide.

Energy.gov.au notes that not all heat pump models are designed for places where the temperature regularly drops below 5°C in winter. If your home sits in a spot that gets that cold in winter, the heat pump you choose needs to be a model designed for colder conditions.

When Solar Hot Water Suits an Illawarra Home Best

Solar hot water suits a home with a sunny roof that faces roughly north and is not shaded by trees or buildings for long periods. Your Home says a collector can face up to 45 degrees away from true north without a big drop in performance, and that winter shade matters most because the sun sits low in the sky.

The time of day your household uses hot water also matters. Water in a solar tank cools overnight, so a household that showers mostly in the early morning may rely on the booster to reheat it before the sun has a chance. Your Home says this can push up energy bills, and suggests a timer or app control on the booster to manage it.

Before we recommend solar hot water, we look at your roof orientation, your water usage and the way your home already gets its energy.

When a Heat Pump Suits an Illawarra Home Best

A heat pump suits a home where the roof is shaded, faces the wrong way or is already covered in solar panels, because it does not need roof collectors at all. It also suits a straight swap from an old electric tank, since Your Home says an integrated heat pump connects the same way as a standard electric storage system.

If you already have rooftop solar panels, a heat pump can work well with them. Your Home says many heat pumps have timers that let you heat the water during the day using spare power from your panels. It also says a heat pump powered by solar panels offers many of the same advantages as solar hot water, and can sometimes be cheaper to install and run.

A heat pump needs good airflow because it draws air in and blows it back out. An enclosed cupboard is not suitable, so most heat pumps go outside or in a well ventilated garage or utility area. If your current hot water system is in a tight spot inside the house, we will discuss the options with you before we quote.

Is a Heat Pump Noisy Compared With Solar Hot Water?

A heat pump makes some noise, so its install spot needs more thought than a set of solar collectors on the roof. Energy.gov.au says the compressor can be noisy. Your Home adds that on an integrated unit the fan sits up high, so the sound can carry over a fence towards a neighbour’s windows or your own bedroom.

A split heat pump helps here because the outdoor unit sits lower and can go in a spot away from bedrooms and boundary fences. Your Home also notes that the outdoor unit of a split system can be placed somewhere warmer to improve its efficiency.

What About Heat Pump vs Gas Hot Water?

Some Illawarra homes are weighing a heat pump against gas hot water rather than solar. Energy.gov.au describes gas water heaters as having medium to high purchase, installation and running costs, and says gas storage systems are particularly inefficient, especially in cold climates. Your Home puts gas systems at a coefficient of performance of 0.75 to 0.96, against around 3 to 5 for a heat pump.

Switching from a gas hot water system to a heat pump means capping the existing gas connection and connecting the new system to your electrical supply. CS Plumbing Services handles the full changeover, gas and plumbing, under one licence. If you would rather stay with gas, our gas hot water page covers the gas systems we install.

What We Check Before Recommending a Heat Pump or Solar Hot Water System

We base the recommendation on your household and your property rather than on whatever system is in stock. When we assess your home, we look at these points:

  • How many people live in the home and when they use hot water.
  • Which way the roof faces and how much shade it gets.
  • Whether you already have rooftop solar panels.
  • Where the new system can go, with enough airflow for a heat pump.
  • Whether your current hot water runs on a controlled load (off-peak) tariff.

The tariff point matters because Your Home says some heat pumps are not compatible with controlled load circuits. If your current system is on off-peak power, we will explain whether a standard tariff makes more sense with the new system. Rebates can also change the upfront cost of both systems, and our heat pump installation page explains the schemes and how we apply them to your quote.

Once we have assessed your home, you get a fixed quote before any work starts. There is no call-out fee for the assessment. Call 0416 101 022 or send us your details to book a visit.

Frequently Asked Questions About Heat Pump vs Solar Hot Water

Are heat pump hot water systems worth it?

For many homes, yes. Energy.gov.au says heat pumps are expensive to buy and install but cheap to run, using 30% of the energy of a conventional electric system. They suit homes without a sunny roof, and the install spot needs good airflow and some distance from bedrooms because of the compressor noise.

Does solar hot water work on cloudy days?

Yes, with help from the booster. Your Home says most solar hot water systems come with a gas or electric booster that heats the water on cloudy days or when demand is higher than the sun can supply. We integrate an electric or gas booster with the solar systems we install, so the household still has hot water.

Can a heat pump use power from my rooftop solar panels?

Yes. Your Home says many heat pumps have built-in timers that can be set to heat water during the day, when spare solar power is most likely to be available. If the panels are not producing enough during the timer window, the heat pump uses power from the grid instead.

Can my existing electric hot water tank be kept?

Sometimes. Your Home says some standard electric storage tanks can be attached to a split heat pump or a split solar unit, and some heat pumps can be fitted to an existing tank. Ask us about your current tank when we assess your home, and we will explain whether it can stay.

Which is better for my Illawarra home, a heat pump or solar hot water?

It depends on your roof, your yard and your daily routine. Solar hot water suits a sunny, unshaded roof facing roughly north. A heat pump suits a shaded roof, a roof already covered in solar panels or a simple swap from an electric tank. CS Plumbing Services can assess your home and recommend the system that fits it.

Book a Heat Pump or Solar Hot Water Assessment in the Illawarra

If your hot water system is getting old, choose its replacement before it fails so the decision is not made in a rush. CS Plumbing Services installs heat pump and solar hot water systems across Wollongong, Shellharbour, Kiama and the wider Illawarra. We will look at your roof, your install spot and your household’s hot water use, then explain which system we recommend and why.

If your current system has already stopped working, our guide to a hot water system that is not heating explains what we check first. For every system type we install, visit our hot water page. To book an assessment, call 0416 101 022 and Sandro or the team will arrange a time to visit.

Sources: Australian Government, energy.gov.au, Hot water systems, retrieved 2026-10-30, https://www.energy.gov.au/households/hot-water-systems. Australian Government, Your Home, Hot water systems, retrieved 2026-10-30, https://www.yourhome.gov.au/energy/hot-water-systems.

Contact Us

Our Services

Residential PlumberCommercial PlumberBlocked DrainsEmergency PlumberHot Water SystemsBathroom PlumbingDrainage PlumbingGas Fitting

Get A Free Quote

Contact us for a free, no-obligation quote on your plumbing needs.

  • 0416-101-022
  • info@csplumbingservices.com.au
  • Illawarra, New South Wales, Australia
Get Your Free Quote Today